Sourdough English Muffins (Soft, Buttery, and Naturally Leavened)

Last Updated on November 3, 2025 by Gabby Hatten

If youโ€™ve ever picked up a warm breakfast sandwich on your way to work or co-op โ€” that golden, toasty English muffin stacked with egg, cheese, and maybe a slice of bacon โ€” you know how satisfying it can be. The best part? You can recreate that same comfort at home with simple ingredients, a jar of sourdough starter, and a cast iron pan. These sourdough English muffins are soft, buttery, and full of flavor โ€” and once you see how easy they are, youโ€™ll never need to buy a drive-thru version again.

What I love most about making them from scratch is how they fit into the rhythm of home life. The dough ferments overnight while the house is quiet, and by morning, itโ€™s ready to shape and cook while coffee brews and the day slowly begins. Theyโ€™re cozy, budget-friendly, and a small reminder that homemade doesnโ€™t have to mean complicated. Just simple ingredients, time, and a bit of warmth from the griddle.

Why I Love This Recipe in Winter

This is one of those sourdough recipes that feels made for wintertime. When our house is cold and the wood stove is burning low, I can leave this dough on the counter for a long, slow ferment without worrying about it overproofing. The cooler air gives the dough plenty of time to develop that perfect sourdough flavor and texture โ€” soft, airy, and slightly tangy.

If your home runs warmer (especially in summer), simply move the overnight ferment to the refrigerator instead. The chilled rest slows everything down and keeps your dough from becoming overly sour or collapsing. Either way, youโ€™ll wake up to a beautifully risen dough ready to shape and cook โ€” perfect for those cozy weekend mornings when everyoneโ€™s still in pajamas and youโ€™ve got coffee brewing.

Serving Ideas

  • Butter + homemade jam
  • Breakfast sandwiches with eggs and cheese
  • Honey + cinnamon butter
  • For the ultimate cozy breakfast, pair them with your favorite fall latte or tea and poetry time!

Sourdough Troubleshooting: English Muffin Edition

๐Ÿซง My dough feels sticky.
Sourdough hydration can vary based on flour brand and humidity. If the dough feels too wet or sticky, dust your hands and work surface with a small amount of flour when shaping. It should feel soft and supple โ€” not tight or dry.

โฐ My muffins turned out dense.
This usually means the dough didnโ€™t ferment long enough or your starter wasnโ€™t very active. Make sure your starter is bubbly before mixing, or allow a longer ferment next time (especially in cooler months).

๐Ÿ”ฅ The outside cooked too fast.
If the muffins are browning quickly but still doughy inside, your skillet is too hot. Keep it on low heat and cook with a lid on โ€” that gentle steam helps them rise evenly while cooking through.

๐Ÿฅถ Overproofing concerns.
In winter, your dough can safely rest on the counter overnight without overproofing. In warmer weather, move it to the refrigerator for the overnight ferment to slow things down and preserve structure.

๐Ÿž The flavor is too sour.
A long, warm ferment can lead to a stronger tang. To mellow it out, shorten the bulk fermentation or refrigerate sooner. Using fresher starter (fed within 8โ€“12 hours) also helps balance flavor.

sourdough english muffins

Sourdough English Muffins

Soft, buttery sourdough English muffins with that classic golden crust and tender interior โ€” perfect for stacking into your favorite breakfast sandwich or slathering with butter and jam. Naturally leavened and budget-friendly, these are the ultimate cozy weekend bake.
Prep Time 25 minutes
Cook Time 20 minutes
Rise 10 hours
Total Time 10 hours 45 minutes
Serving Size 12 people

Ingredients

  • 360 g Whole milk
  • 60 g Unsalted butter
  • 80 g Sourdough starter active or discard
  • 30 g Honey
  • 510 g All-purpose flour
  • 7 g Salt
  • Semolina flour for dusting, optional โ€”

Instructions

Warm the Milk & Butter

  • In a small saucepan, gently warm the milk and butter over low heat, being careful not to scald. Once the butter is melted, remove from heat and let cool until just warm to the touch.

Combine Wet Ingredients

  • In the bowl of a stand mixer, whisk together the sourdough starter and honey.
  • Pour in the milk and butter mixture and whisk again to combine.

Add Dry Ingredients

  • Add the flour and salt. Mix on low speed with the dough hook for 5โ€“10 minutes, until a soft, smooth dough forms. The dough should feel tacky but not sticky.

Bulk Ferment

  • Cover and let rest at room temperature for 2โ€“4 hours.
  • (Optional: perform 2โ€“3 sets of stretch and folds during this window to strengthen the dough.)
  • Afterward, cover tightly and ferment overnight at room temperature or in the refrigerator.

Shape the Muffins

  • Turn the dough onto a lightly floured surface and divide into 12 equal pieces (about 80โ€“85g each).
  • Shape each one into a smooth round, similar to a dinner roll or burger bun.
  • Place onto a baking sheet dusted with semolina flour, leaving space between each piece. Dust the tops lightly as well.

Final Rise

  • Cover and let the muffins rise for about 1 hour, or until puffy and slightly domed.

Cook

  • Preheat a cast iron skillet or heavy pan over low heat. Lightly butter the surface and place a few muffins in at a time.
  • Cover with a lid and cook for 8โ€“10 minutes per side, until golden brown and cooked through.
  • Cool slightly before slicing โ€” and fork-split them to preserve all those perfect nooks and crannies.

Notes

  • Fermentation: A long, slow ferment develops flavor and improves texture. The overnight rest is key to that soft, airy crumb.
  • Cooking Tip: Keep the heat low and the pan covered โ€” this ensures even cooking without burning the outside.
  • Flour Variation: Iโ€™ll be testing a fresh-milled version soon using soft white wheat โ€” check back for updates!
  • Freezing: Once cooled, freeze in a single layer, then store in a bag for up to 3 months. Toast straight from frozen.

Author Profile

Gabby Hatten
Gabby Hatten
Hello there, I'm Gabby! I'm a mom of four, married to my wonderful husband Marco, and I have a deep passion for simple living, vintage homes, and cooking everything from scratch! Although I grew up in Las Vegas, my husband's military service brought us to the east coast, where we have now made coastal North Carolina our home. While I didn't grow up on a farm, I have always been fascinated by that lifestyle and have dedicated my adult life to learning and embracing those skills, which I am excited to share with all of you!

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating